Saccharine Trust - Surviving You, AlwaysReleased: 1984
Download album by clicking here
Jared:
'80s hardcore got old quick. If you consider the scene breaking with the popularity of Black Flag in 1981, by 1983 with the demise of Minor Threat, you were simply left with a group of teenagers copying each other. Not to mention that at this point you had Greg Ginn's SST basically signing template bands to his label when it came to new hardcore. Basically, the scene was in shambles and if you were looking for intelligent, musically provoking bands you had to look towards groups such as Husker Du and The Replacements, who were taking ideas from hardcore but making the music much more accessible. Saccharine Trust was a diamond in the rough combining a Fear-like rhythm section with the "jazz" influenced playing of later Black Flag. Saccharine Trust wasn't about sticking to a template, they were about advancing it.
"Surviving You Always" is a dizzying experience. Instead of following the typical two-step approach of most of the hardcore in their day, Saccharine Trust was into being varied in the delivery of aggression. While at times it works wonderfully (Opener "The Giver Takes" and "The House, The System, The Concrete"), sometimes it feels like Saccharine Trust is just trying to fuck with their audience ("Remnants"). Still, the bands' unique approach to making hardcore that is basically the equivalent of "free jazz" to "jazz" is incredibly original, especially for their time. While bands like the Minutemen were certainly incorporating technicality into their music, Saccharine Trust was just on a whole 'nother plain. Like most "free jazz" groups though, Saccharine Trust falls into the pitfall of sounding too similar at times, which really makes "Surviving You Always" suffer. Thankfully, the band is at least somewhat aware of this flaw and throws in songs like the cover of the Doors' "Peace Frog", and "The Cat Cracker" which features some excellent saxophone playing.
All in all, "Surviving You Always" is an excellent example of forward-thinking hardcore. While it is rough around the edges, it will certainly be a fan to any fan of hardcore and probably be a good transistor from a jazz fan into the genre. Saccharine Trust attempted to do something different in a genre where fitting a template is usually the norm, and in so created music that is certainly influential as well as timeless.
Rating: 7.0/10
Burton:
Los Angeles outfit Saccharine Trust were associated with the hardcore scene despite their unyielding oddities: similar to other bizarre hardcore acts such as Flipper and No Trend, they were stuck in the scene by virtue of their occasional fast tempos and the constant, steadfast independence that defined punk rock at the time. Thanks to their relation to Greg Ginn, the Black Flag guitarist and head of the pioneering SST Records, Saccharine earned an integral place in the SoCal hardcore scene in the early eighties, and most remarkably of all, their sound was rooted more in jazz than hardcore, with vocalist Jack Brewer spouting verse like a lost beat poet and guitarist Joe Baiza laying down free jazz solos as the rhythm section supports with offbeat grooves. And yet, the hardcore/jazz combination works almost perfectly in the hands of this band on '83's Surviving You, Always.
The cover depicts a woman in recess, which Brewer later claimed was a woman who jumped off the Empire State Building. It certainly goes with the mood of Surviving You, Always, which tends to reside in a gloomy, almost frightening atmosphere, constantly seething with emotion that was rarely so broad in the hardcore scene, at least until the mid-eighties. The beat is rarely fast enough to keep up with hardcore front-runners, but Saccharine makes up for this with their sheer talent. Many bands of this period were young, and made their presence known on speed and raw energy while not having any real musical experience, whereas Saccharine is content to amble along as long as a weaving bass line or frantic solo is accompanying the dirge. This makes it even more amazing that this band was able to hold their own amongst their inclusive contemporaries.
Admittedly, the formula ST has for their songs on Surviving You does grow tedious (especially in the more lengthy numbers such as "Our Discovery" and "YHWH on Acid") but luckily this release is relatively short at under forty minutes and on most tracks they change things up reasonably fast. Despite the small lo-fi sound, you can hear the energy in many of these tracks, with "Peace Frog" being the real mover you could imagine them pulling out for the crowd to get into. It's fortunate that many of these songs are good enough in this regard, as they really put the dynamics of the eighties scene in perspective for a modern audience, possibly even more so than a more typical hardcore act.
Listening to Surviving You, Always, it still remains uncoupled in its oddity and still draws wonder in the band's ability to make their presence known in a furious scene they seemingly had little place in. These factors along with the band's obvious eclecticism and musicianship make the album worth a listen, especially for those interested in atypical early hardcore that was not afraid to push the envelope to the fullest. Depending on your musical preference (hardcore, jazz or both), Surviving You may be Saccharine Trust's best record and their crowning achievement.
Rating: 8/10






